Wheat Market Outlook and Prices
The Wheat Market Outlook is provided by Mercantile Consulting Venture Inc.
World Wheat Overview
US Wheat production as per the USDA’s Sept 30th Small Grains Summary
The USDA Small Grains Summary did not reduce the HRS or durum crop despite expectations of lost acres, nor did they raise the HRW crop! The total wheat crop was put at 1.961 bln bu, 6 mln bu lower that trade guesses, but 77 mln bu higher than last year.
Total spring wheat production (other than durum) was seen at 600 mln bu (16.3 mln t), down 4% from the 2018 total of 623 mln bu (16.95 mln mt).Of this, 559 mln bu (15.2 mln mt) was Hard Red Spring wheat, down 5% from the 2018 total. Given our analysis, and the adverse harvest weather, the HRS production estimate is almost certainly too high.
The US yield was estimated at 48.3 bu/ac, tied with the 2018 record high. A record high yield was estimated in North Dakota for 2019.
The USDA ignoring the poor harvest conditions in the N Plains was negative for Minneapolis futures, however, NASS followed the report with a statement that they “may update acreage, yield, production and stocks estimates for barley, oats, durum and other spring wheat” in their November 8 Crop Production report as there was “significant unharvested acreage” of these crops when the small grains survey was carried out.
Global wheat production and trade
There is a lot of competition in the wheat markets as wheat is produced around the world. Below is a brief synopsis on last week’s market events in the major wheat origins.
Futures: Dec '19 contract Chicago winter wheat closed at 490-4, up 1-6 cents from yesterday and up 3-0 cents for the week.
Dec ‘19 contract Kansas hard red winter wheat closed at 404-0, down 1-6 cents for the day, down 3-0 cents for the week.
In Minneapolis, Dec '19 contract hard red spring wheat closed at 536-0, up 6-4 cents for the day, down 11-4 cents for the week while March ’20 hard red spring wheat closed at 549-6, up 6-4 cents for the day, down 10-4 cents for the week.
The Northern regions of the Canadian Prairies were able to avoid much of the precipitation over the week, while Sothern AB, SK and MB all received rain. The forecast shows a short harvest window this week before another early season snowstorm and rain returns later in the week.
According to SAF and MB Ag, spring wheat harvest was able to progress 13% in SK to 44% complete (as of Sept 30th), and 5% in MB to 91% complete (as of Oct 1st). AB Ag was showing their spring wheat harvest 35% complete as of Oct. 1st (up 8% from the prev. wk). NASS in the US reported the US spring wheat crop 90% complete, current harvest data and USDA/Stats Canada’s projected production estimates suggest there is ~14 mln mt worth of spring wheat (excl. durum) in N America remaining to be harvested. This is ~35% of all expected production.
Saskatchewan Wheat Harvest Progress
Like HRS, durum harvest has been slow, and quality will be a major issue this year. In SK, 57% of the durum crop has been harvested as of Sept 30th. There was no update for the AB durum crop which was reportedly 85% harvested as of Sept 23rd.
Using a similar calculation as above for spring wheat, we estimate that there is still 2.276 mln mt worth of durum in North American remaining to be harvested.
Canadian producers delivered 698.8k mt of wheat (excl. durum) into the Canadian grain handling system during week 8 of the 2019/20 marketing year. Exports during the week were 278.7k mt, for a YTD total of 2.456 mln mt, 402.8k mt (14%) less than this time last year.
Meanwhile,112.5k worth of durum was delivered into the grain handling system during week 8 of the marketing year. Exports during the week were 90k mt for a YTD total of 758 mt, 63% (291.6k mt) higher than this time last year. Facilitating the strong early-season exports is the larger 2018/19 durum carry-out.
Wheat values - Important to those farmers who have harvested lesser qualities: Korea was a good buyer of feed wheat as a substitute for corn last week. The price paid was at a parity of C$5.50 delivered elevator Saskatchewan, which makes Canadian elevator bids for feed wheat far too low relative o international markets for feed wheat.
Also re. spring wheat/ durum quality harvested, keep in mind: “When the best is gone, the best is left”.
In the USDA quarterly Stocks Report, US Sept 1 wheat stocks were 67 mln bu (1.8 mln mt) higher than trade expected at 2.385 bln bu (64.9 mln bu), just 5 mln bu lower than last year.
USDA’s Small Grains Summary was seen as negative for Minneapolis wheat because it did not reflect the poor harvest conditions in the N Plains. NASS did come out with a statement that they “may update acreage, yield, production and stocks estimates for barley, oats, durum and other spring wheat” in their November 8 Crop Production report. In our opinion, especially given the adverse harvest weather, the USDA’s HRS production estimate is almost certainly too high.
NASS is reporting that US spring wheat harvest progressed 3% from last week to 90% complete. MT and ND the furthest behind at 84% and 89% complete respectively.
According to samples analyzed by the US wheat associates, average spring wheat protein and test weight is consistent at 14.5% and 60.3 lb/bu respectively. The average falling number lost 4 points from last week to 379 seconds (vs last year’s 414 seconds). Color and vitreous kernel counts have also fallen from the rain; down 1% from the week, at 62%, down 28% from last year.
US, durum harvest was able to progress 5% in both MT and ND who are now at 55% and 78% harvested respectively. The ND Wheat Commission says it is likely that some of the crop will not be harvested.
The average falling number of the US durum crop is now 362 seconds vs 374 last week and 418 last year. Protein remained consistent at 13.7% vs 14.2% last year. Average HVAC was reported 2% higher than last week at 62%, still well below last year’s 88%.
US winter wheat planting is 39% complete vs 41% last year and the 38% average.
The drought in Australia continues to expand and intensify. Both ABARES and the USDA are estimating a 19 mln mt crop, while many private estimates are falling below 17 mln mt.
Aussie futures made 12-month highs early in the week. Although falling sharply on Friday, they still managing to close higher for the week.
Fob values were essentially unchanged for the week at $240/mt, but will only sell to the most inelastic export markets and domestic feeding.
Crop ratings in Argentina fell another 5%, to 30% Gd/Ex, vs 42% last year. Twenty-six percent of Argentina’s crop is heading (50% last year and 38% avg.). Strangely, optimum moisture ratings of 66% is well ahead of last year’s 54% while their “dry” area is up to 9% vs 5% last week. Wheat harvest in Argentina has just begun and current yields are 1.5-1.8 tph. There is no data for this time period from last year to compare with.
One-fifth of the Argentina’s growing area, accounting for 30% of their wheat production, is under drought conditions. As the crop is now at its highest level in terms of moisture requirements. Buenos Aires Grain Exchange has lowered wheat production forecasts another 3 mln mt to 17 mln mt (USDA’s 20.5 mln mt).
The wheat market in Argentina seems to finally be reacting to the prolonged dryness. Offers for 12.5 pro are up $2-3 from last week at $187.
In their latest update of EU all wheat supply and disposition, Brussels raised 2019/20 production 2.2 mln mt to 152.8 mln mt (vs the USDA’s 151 mln mt). This is a 15.3 mln mt increase over the drought-stricken crop of last year. Carry-in and imports were unchanged from last month for a 2.2 mln increase in total supply to 172.7 mln mt, 9.6 mln mt higher than last year. Demand was seen slightly higher at 154 mln mt (vs the the USDA’s 155 mln mt) because of a 100k mt increase in domestic use. Overall, ending stocks were revised 2.1 mln mt higher from last month to 18.7 mln mt (vs the USDA’s 11.6 mln mt), up 4.2 mln mt from last year.
The main difference between Brussels’ numbers and the USDA is the ending stocks with the USDA’s number representing just 3.9 weeks supply which we think is unreasonable. Brussels sees stocks being 29% higher than last year (7 mln mt above the USDA’s number) which represents a more realistic 6.3 weeks supply.
Wet weather is hindering winter wheat planting in France. French farmers have only been able to plant 1% of the total expected area as of Oct 4th.
At the end of last week French Fob, who took most of the tender business last week, was bid at $192.7 for 11.5 pro, Baltic 12.5 pro was $191, while German 12.5 pro was bid at 192.7.
Black Sea wheat:
Total Ukrainian wheat exports as of Oct 1st are 61% higher than last year at 8.62 mln mt. The USDA is currently estimating that the country will export 19 mln mt of wheat this MY, up 21% from last year. Additionally, Ukraine’s Gov’t is eliminating its formal cap on wheat exports and is instead “monitoring market conditions on a monthly basis to ensure adequate domestic supply.”
Russia’s wheat harvest now totals 75.6 mln mt as of Oct 4th vs 69.7 mln mt this time last year. Russia’s Ag Min is still estimating their crop will be 78 mln mt.
The volume of Black Sea wheat offered at last week’s GASC tender was significantly smaller than previous tenders with Fob values reflecting a $5 rise in futures/cash prices since GASC’s last purchase.
Russian Fob ended the week at $195 and $192 for 12.5 pro and 11.5 pro respectively. Feed wheat from Korea’s Dec deliv. purchase at $226 C&F which reflects $200 Fob Vancouver parity.
Significant purchases/ trades:
Egypt (GASC) bought just 60,000 mt of French for 5-15 Nov at $219.35, some $5 above the previous tender.
Under the respective tariff quotas, Morocco awarded 576,000 mt of EU milling wheat, but just 30,000 mt for the USA.
Korea bought 60,000 mt of Dec feed wheat at around $226 C&F.
USA inspections were 467,000 mt (season total 312 mln bu up 23%), sales were 329,000 mt. The season total is now 474 mln bushels up 14% on last year, but the gap continues to narrow.
Wheat Market Outlook
Winter wheat futures were supported following the surprisingly low stock report for corn. The low number suggests that the USDA had either overestimated production or underestimated demand for 2018/9.
The USDA’s Small Grains Summary was seen as negative for Spring Wheat as the association did not reflect the impact of the late/poor harvest. We think the USDA’s numbers are too high and will need to be lowered. With more snow in the forecast the question is turning from “what will the quality be?” to “how much will be unharvested?”
YTD wheat consumption has been very strong. EU exports are already 600,000 tonnes more than last year and are being underestimated by the USDA. The Korean feed wheat purchases, were are at a small discount to milling wheat. Feed wheat keyed off of Korea's Dec purchase at $226, equates to around US$200.00/mt Fob Vancouver parity.
We need to pay attention to Korean feed wheat purchases, which are at a small discount to milling wheat. Feed wheat based on Korea's Dec purchase was valued at US$226/mt, which equates to around US$200.00/mt Fob Vancouver parity (~$5.50/bu dlvd elevator SK). This makes current Canadian elevator bids for feed wheat far too low.
Weather around the world:
The USA is turning cooler and looks considerably drier this week except in the northcentral regions where heavy snow is expected. Canada has also turned colder and here too significant snow is expected. South America again looks mostly dry this week with the exception of North East Argentina and Southern Brazil. South Africa remains warm and mostly dry. The drought in Australia is expected to expand and intensify with only the eastern seaboard seeing any rain.
The attention of the market will be focused on the new WASDE report due to be released on the 10th of October. In our view, the report should reduce the ending stocks in for the 2018/19 corn crop and reduce the USDA‘s estimate of 2019/20 production. This in turn should support wheat futures due to higher feed wheat usage. We do not expect any significant revisions in wheat, other than perhaps spring wheat & durum. The USDA may again be conservative in this report, but their numbers have been wrong recently, and their errors have been noticed by the markets.
The Southern Hemisphere is taking on increasing importance as dryness cuts crop potential. The concern by millers over quality and how much of the Canadian crop might not even get harvested is growing with the return of snow forecast later this week.
Feed wheat seems to be undervalued at Cdn. elevators right now relative to recent trades of feed wheat into Korea.
We see no reasons to sell the markets at this time in front of the WASDE report.
Primary Elevator Bids
Primary elevator bids data source: PDQ